If you’re reading this list and haven’t played Red Dead Redemption, go find yourself a copy of the game and the appropriate console to play it on. Right now. We’ll wait the 30+ hours – this is important.
2008’s GTA 4 may have been the reason that I bought an Xbox 360, but RDR is the reason I kept it. Not only did I get completely lost in the massive single-player world, to the point where I’d started talking with a bit of a drawl because I was so used to hearing it, but it also drew me into online gaming unlike anything I’d played before. Sure, CoD was fun for a bit and racing games were okay, but never before had I so successfully crafted my own stories and adventures (with friends and strangers alike) than in Red Dead’s Free Roam mode.
It was the kind of game you couldn’t wait to discuss with your friends the next day. “Did you save that woman on the train tracks?” “No, but I found this cabin that had, like, 1,000 cougars in it,” “That’s cool, but did you kill Sasquatch?” Everyone had their own amazing tales to tell about their time in the old west, and you were constantly making new ones every time you turned it on. The only real downside to Red Dead is that it never came out on PC – which is mostly sad because my 360 died years ago and I really want to play it again.